• site home
  • blog home
  • galleries
  • contact
  • underwater
  • the bleeding edge

the last word

Photography meets digital computer technology. Photography wins -- most of the time.

You are here: Home / The Last Word / Histograms, high contrast scene

Histograms, high contrast scene

May 19, 2023 JimK 1 Comment

Here’s the scene, photographed with a Hasselblad X2D, 90mm XCD lens, and developed in Lightroom with default settings.

Here’s the raw histogram, log-log presentation:

Looks like it’s ETTR, but maybe too conservative.

Here’s the raw histogram with a linear y-axis:

That makes it look a stop or so underexposed from ETTR.

Here’s the in-camera histogram:

That looks like ETTR.

Here’s what the image looks like after I developed it to taste in Lightroom

Could we have given a more generous exposure?

Here’s an image with a stop longer shutter speed.

Here’s the raw histogram for that shot:

This looks like ETTR, but the log log plot shows that it’s a bit hot:

There are almost 5000 pixels clipped in each green raw channel.

The in-camera histogram looks like this:

The red channel looks close to clipping, but the red raw channel is a stop and a half lower. The green channel looks only slightly hotter than the green raw channels. I think that’s because the highlights are mostly green.

Here’s the histogram in Lightroom at default settings plus Daylight white balance:

And here’s the developed to taste image:

The obvious question is: “Are there any significant differences in the highlights and shadows of the two images that are different in exposure by a stop?”

Let’s look at the shadows first. At a little over 100% magnification:

1/30 second exposure

 

1/15 second exposure

I turned down the sharpening from Lightroom’s grotesque default of amount = 40. I set it to 20, and left everything else alone. It is clear that the more generous exposure produces cleaner shadows. No surprise there.

What about the highlights?

1/30 second exposure

 

1/15 second exposure

Sorry about the screen door artifacts and the subject motion in the 1/15 second image. I wouldn’t call anything in the longer exposure blown in any significant way. If Lightroom is reconstructing the detail in the leaf in the upper left quadrant of the image, it is doing a credible job.

This is a case where relying on the log log histogram reduces image quality.

The Last Word

← Histograms, low contrast scene with specular highlight Specularity →

Comments

  1. Haitong Yu says

    May 20, 2023 at 9:20 am

    Jim, I am amazed to see this blog is still up and running! Hope you are getting better! Despite of my desire to see more posts (especially reviews of XCD 90 V), I hope you take your time and don’t hurry it. Good health!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

May 2025
S M T W T F S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
« Apr    

Articles

  • About
    • Patents and papers about color
    • Who am I?
  • How to…
    • Backing up photographic images
    • How to change email providers
    • How to shoot slanted edge images for me
  • Lens screening testing
    • Equipment and Software
    • Examples
      • Bad and OK 200-600 at 600
      • Excellent 180-400 zoom
      • Fair 14-30mm zoom
      • Good 100-200 mm MF zoom
      • Good 100-400 zoom
      • Good 100mm lens on P1 P45+
      • Good 120mm MF lens
      • Good 18mm FF lens
      • Good 24-105 mm FF lens
      • Good 24-70 FF zoom
      • Good 35 mm FF lens
      • Good 35-70 MF lens
      • Good 60 mm lens on IQ3-100
      • Good 63 mm MF lens
      • Good 65 mm FF lens
      • Good 85 mm FF lens
      • Good and bad 25mm FF lenses
      • Good zoom at 24 mm
      • Marginal 18mm lens
      • Marginal 35mm FF lens
      • Mildly problematic 55 mm FF lens
      • OK 16-35mm zoom
      • OK 60mm lens on P1 P45+
      • OK Sony 600mm f/4
      • Pretty good 16-35 FF zoom
      • Pretty good 90mm FF lens
      • Problematic 400 mm FF lens
      • Tilted 20 mm f/1.8 FF lens
      • Tilted 30 mm MF lens
      • Tilted 50 mm FF lens
      • Two 15mm FF lenses
    • Found a problem – now what?
    • Goals for this test
    • Minimum target distances
      • MFT
      • APS-C
      • Full frame
      • Small medium format
    • Printable Siemens Star targets
    • Target size on sensor
      • MFT
      • APS-C
      • Full frame
      • Small medium format
    • Test instructions — postproduction
    • Test instructions — reading the images
    • Test instructions – capture
    • Theory of the test
    • What’s wrong with conventional lens screening?
  • Previsualization heresy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Recommended photographic web sites
  • Using in-camera histograms for ETTR
    • Acknowledgments
    • Why ETTR?
    • Normal in-camera histograms
    • Image processing for in-camera histograms
    • Making the in-camera histogram closely represent the raw histogram
    • Shortcuts to UniWB
    • Preparing for monitor-based UniWB
    • A one-step UniWB procedure
    • The math behind the one-step method
    • Iteration using Newton’s Method

Category List

Recent Comments

  • JimK on Goldilocks and the three flashes
  • DC Wedding Photographer on Goldilocks and the three flashes
  • Wedding Photographer in DC on The 16-Bit Fallacy: Why More Isn’t Always Better in Medium Format Cameras
  • JimK on Fujifilm GFX 100S II precision
  • Renjie Zhu on Fujifilm GFX 100S II precision
  • JimK on Fuji 20-35/4 landscape field curvature at 23mm vs 23/4 GF
  • Ivo de Man on Fuji 20-35/4 landscape field curvature at 23mm vs 23/4 GF
  • JimK on Fuji 20-35/4 landscape field curvature at 23mm vs 23/4 GF
  • JimK on Fuji 20-35/4 landscape field curvature at 23mm vs 23/4 GF
  • Ivo de Man on Fuji 20-35/4 landscape field curvature at 23mm vs 23/4 GF

Archives

Copyright © 2025 · Daily Dish Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Unless otherwise noted, all images copyright Jim Kasson.